EMI ("Emmy"), or Experiments in Musical Intelligence,
is a program for composing music in the styles of famous
composers. One recent test involved a piece by Bach, one by
Dr. Steven Larson, and one by EMI. The audience judged that
EMI's piece was genuine Bach and that Larson's simple two-part
invention was written by a computer. EMI, by David Cope of
UC Santa Cruz, "has no passions, no memories, and knows nothing
about life," but composes music that speaks to those who do.
A CD of EMI's compositions, called "Classical Music Composed
by Computer" is being released by Centaur Records. It includes
artificial Bach, Beethoven, Chopin, Rachmaninoff, Mozart,
Stravinsky, and Scott Joplin. EMI's mastery isn't perfect,
but "It's certainly in the ballpark." Douglas Hofstadter
called EMI "the most thought-provoking project in artificial
intelligence that I have ever come across. ... To what extent
is music composed of `riffs', as jazz people say? If that
is mostly the case, then it would mean that, to my absolute
devastation, music is much less than previously thought."
EMI may undermine Hofstadter's position that self-reference
and human experience underlie the highest levels of creativity,
although he takes comfort that EMI only copies the styles of
others -- especially refined, mathematical composers such as
Bach -- and is only convincing over spans of a few seconds.
"It is like listening to random lines from a Keats sonnet.
You wonder what was happening to Keats that day. Was he
completely drunk?" Cope admits that "EMI produces beautiful
music but maybe not profound music," although it is competitive
with human emulators. He is still working on capturing
musical personality. [George Johnson, NYT, 29Nov98.
Hans Moravec , comp.ai, 04Jan98.] (Moravec
believes that "the real core of high intelligence is the ability
to distill good answers from astronomical quantities of noisy
and contradictory information. Self-reference is a cute
little frill built on top of that.")
Niall Griffith and Peter Todd are making available
their bibliography of connectionist publications on music,
from a book they've edited for MIT Press this summer: "Musical
Networks: Parallel Distributed Perception and Performance."
See ,
and contact with any additions.
[connectionists, 28May98.]
Andrew Horner uses genetic algorithms to do timbre matching
and voice leading. He has articles published in the latest
CMJ, AES journal, and ICMC proceedings. Lee Spector has also
used genetic programming to evolve jazz musicians. See
for info on project GeneBop.
[James McCartney and Sean Luke
, comp.music.research, 20Jan98.]
Musicae Scientiae is a journal from the European Society
for the Cognitive Sciences of Music, replacing the
ESCOM Newsletter after Oct96. Abstracts are available
at . [ESCOM Secretariat
, newjour, 16Jul97.]
"The Classical Music Cube ... The Music Beat" is a good place
for newcomers to classical music on the Internet. It offers
history and style lessons, musical terms, and links to other
classical music sites. .
[, net-hap, 18Mar98.]
Scott Downie is a 12-year Mac fan, but warns against
installing Mac OS 8.1 if you've got copy-protected music
software from Opcode, Mark of the Unicorn, Steinberg, or others.
He's fed up with the insult and hassles of copy protection,
and is at least tempted to switch to Cakewalk Pro Audio
under Windows 98. [, comp.music.midi,
28Jan98.]
The British Phonographic Industry is objecting to
RealNetworks' RealAudio software combined with Audio Rack.
RealAudio provides real-time music streams that are never
fully resident on your hard disk, but other software can capture
a stream and make it recordable. However, quality is limited to
that provided by the RealAudio server. [TechWeb, 07May98. EduP.]
For more about music software, get the monthly Shareware
Music Machine Newsletter from .
It covers both Mac and PC shareware -- including Windows, DOS,
and Linux -- listed by download popularity.
[ or ,
rec.music.makers.synth, 14Mar98.]